The Terrible Twos: Myth or Reality?

Toddler-tantrum
Image adapted via © Pmariann | Stock Free Images

Are toddlers truly “terrible?” Have the “Terrible Twos” earned their reputation? I am asking these questions because my previously sweet and easygoing baby has turned into a screaming, demanding toddler. Is this behavior normal?

I turned to parenting expert and family physician Dr. Deborah Gilboa (popularly known as Dr. G) to answer some of these pressing questions about toddler behavior.

So, why has my toddler seemingly become another person? Dr. G says, “Some kids have a startling behavior development at age two. For some it's not until age three. The really wily ones wait and have you convinced [that] you got through clean and then start to really test you at four!”

There is also a difference in toddlers who are being raised as an only child as opposed to toddlers who have an older sibling. According to Dr. G, tantrum throwing in 2-year-olds is usually an expression of frustration and more common in younger siblings. This is because they see their older sibling communicating complex ideas and getting their wants met on a regular basis. Because toddlers don't yet have the language skills to express complex thoughts, feelings, or ideas, and they don't have the motor skills necessary to make it happen themselves, they express frustration. It's upsetting to them because they possess the cognitive skills to know what they're missing out on, by they can't do anything about it. On the flip side, however, Dr. G says, “It is a great motivator for them, and they often hit milestones a little sooner because of it.”

{ MORE: Oh Goodness! 3 Weird Things Toddlers Do That Are Perfectly Normal }

terrible-twos-myth-reality-1
Image via iStock

Toddlers are “experts” at whining because it works.

“It is a natural inclination to start whining once a child has [learned] a few words,” says Dr. G. “This is because the tired and frustrated and but-I-really-want-that-and-you-just-don't-understand-me seeps into their voices. I've even heard cats and dogs whine a meow or a woof! But here is the truth: they'll keep whining if it works. On anyone. The trick is to start strong. If he whines ‘Miiiiiiilk, Mooooommmmmmyyyyy!' turn back to him and say calmly to him without whining, ‘Milk please, Mommy.' Help him get the request in the tone you find acceptable before he gets the milk. This takes repetition, but you (and his preschool teacher) will be so happy you did it!”

{ MORE: Check Out These Safety Tips Before Purchasing Toddler Toys }


mother talking with her unhappy son at home
Image via iStock

The next issue I asked Dr. G about was the concept of sharing. For my toddler, when he says, “Share,” he means, “Give it to me.” What should I be doing or saying instead?

It is no surprise that 2-year-olds want what they want and want it right then; they have no sense of fair play or concern about anyone else's feelings. To correct this behavior, Dr. G suggests, “You need to show him [or her] that it does matter … It's great that he uses the word ‘share.' The rule in my house (4 boys!) is [that] any child can say ‘Share, please.' The child with the toy must say ‘Yes' and hand it over or ‘in two minutes.' If the child without the toys grabs it anyway, they don't get a turn at all. If the child with the toy says ‘No!' or doesn't hand it over in two minutes, then they don't get the toy again for a long time. This sort of back and forth takes patience to teach, but [it will carry] on without you for years. It's a worthwhile investment!”

{ MORE: This Party Can Save a Life: Why a CPR Party Should Be Part of Your Summer Plans }


terrible-twos-myth-reality-3
Image via iStock

I have an additional problem of a very bite-happy toddler. It is of great concern to me because he has already bitten his older brother fairly severely, as well as a child at preschool. Dr. G assured me that biting is a very natural (though, of course, unacceptable) instinct. He may be angry or frustrated or both.

But what do I do? How do I stop this unacceptable behavior?

Dr. G suggests that if my son bites a sibling or another child, I should pull him away and clearly and strongly say “No” to him. Then I should set him to my side and focus my attention on the hurt child.

{ MORE: How to Decode Toddler Behavior }

“In this way, you comfort the hurt child and give your [your child] the message that hurting someone does not get him [or her] anything he [or she] desires (especially your focus). Keep in mind that this is a phase and most kids grow out of it without much intervention. However, this can take several months. If [your child] goes to preschool, make sure his [or her] teachers have experience with this and have a plan in the classroom whenever a child bites. They should already–this is that common.”

terrible-twos-myth-reality-4
Image via iStock

Last, but not least, are time-outs. Is it too soon to impose time-outs on a toddler?

I love Dr. G's answer. She says, “Here's how I've always known my child was ready for a time-out. We have a dog water bowl, and we constantly had to pull our crawling babies away from it. Over and over and over again, they would go to play in or try to drink from the water bowl. But one day, around 13 months (or so) old, each of my kids would crawl over, sit next to the water bowl, stick one hand towards it, and look at me instead of the bowl. ‘What are you going to do, Mom?' The look clearly said. That is the moment that a child is ready for a short time-out. The time when he [or she] is looking to you to see what the consequence is rather than towards the object of his [or her] intention. After that age, you know they understand the link between their behavior and the consequence.”

In conclusion, yes, the twos are a little terrible–some more so for some others. However, as Dr. Gilboa has assured me, this phase will pass. Thank goodness.

{ MORE: Positive Parenting Strategies for the Toddler Years }

Are you facing a challenging time with your toddler?

Read More

What do you think?

The Terrible Twos: Myth or Reality?

Alison Lee is a former PR and marketing professional turned work-at-home mother. After a 10-year career in various PR agencies, and of the world’s biggest sports brands, she traded in product launches and world travel, for sippy cups, diapers, and breastfeeding. Alison is a former blogger (Writing, Wishing), and her writing has been featured on Mamalode,On Parenting at The Washington Post,The Huffington Post, Everyday Family, Scary Mommy, Club Mid, andDrGreene.com. She is one of 35 essayists ... More

Tell us what you think!

14 comments

  1. Profile photo of Ashley Ashley says:

    More like the terrible FOURS for us!!!

  2. Profile photo of ovation ovation says:

    My son snapped when he was about 2 1/2. He was so good and sweet before. We always used time outs and he was usually really good about it. Now it was a fight to the end. The meltdowns are epic. There’s some days it’s just exhausting. It’s really hard to keep my cool and deal with him. He never gets what he wants and the tantrums never get him anywhere so his dad and I wonder when he’s going to figure that out. After the tantrum we talk to him and remind him that he really didn’t get what he wanted. We also remind him to use his words. He turned 4 in July and things are slowly starting to get better. He still has meltdowns but they have become shorter. Still get the epic ones every once in awhile. So hang in there to all the parents who have toddlers going through this stage!

  3. Profile photo of espatacean espatacean says:

    O my word! This nailed it! I am going through this with my son right now and he is almost 27 months…so he is right at the terrible twos. The last three days have been ridiculous…..it’s like something snapped in him. He is having very bad tantrums, throwing toys at me and my husband, slamming the toys against the ground. It’s really bad. He is delayed with his speech so maybe this has something to do with it cause he can’t express himself, but it is just really bad. Timeout is not working…he will not sit still at all. Even feeding him is difficult…he just wants to run around and play. He has lots of energy. Not sure what else to do with him. Speaking to him and slowly explaining isn’t working either.

  4. Profile photo of Jessica Jessica says:

    Mine is an only and three was worse for sure. I can definitely see where being an only might put that off for a while. There was no one to compare to!

  5. Profile photo of RF Dietz RF Dietz says:

    Alison nailed this article. My son is 1 and he’s already exuding some of these terrible qualities that popped up overnight. It’s great to hear another mom talk so candidly about the biting and fussing around.

  6. Profile photo of Alanna Alanna says:

    I guess we shall find out!

  7. Total myth! Three was the horrific year. For us anyway.

  8. Profile photo of mommy nhoj mommy nhoj says:

    I just need to pat myself if its reality! Bring it on 🙂

  9. Profile photo of LIZ says:

    im socare of this, i hope i can get thru with no problem

  10. Profile photo of jesster131 jesster131 says:

    My little guy is almost 2 & we are going through it now. It is tough as his speech is a little bit behind. He knows what he is trying to say it’s just not coming out so anybody else knows what he just said so he ends up a pile of tears on the floor. Or the harder part he will try to get or do it himself. he is very independent. That scares me more. He is trying to climb up to the cabinet for a snack because I did not understand that smaasbeeb nasbe beesntreds mum meant snack time now mum. If he wants a drink & I did not understand he will pick up his cup put it in my hand & lead me to the fridge. But other things he either melts down or tris to get himself.

    • Profile photo of Alison LeeAuthor Alison Lee says:

      I’m so sorry you’re going through a tough time with your little guy. As Dr. G points out though, once they gain more language and cognitive ability, the meltdown triggers should pass because he can communicate better. Hang on in there! (you should also check out our other articles/ blogs on speech development)

  11. Profile photo of Timothy Timothy says:

    I am ready to find out which..

×

Send this to a friend